Support OJ 
Contribute Today
En
Support OJ Contribute Today
Search mobile
Opinion

Vladimir Pastukhov: Betting on zero. Can the war end quickly?

Vladimir Pastukhov: Betting on zero. Can the war end quickly?
Article top vertical

By Vladimir Pastukhov

 

Yesterday, a very intelligent and very persistent person kept pushing me to place a “bet” in the political casino on the war ending by the end of this year (give or take), rather than in the spring or summer of next year. And he was not satisfied with a reasonable answer based on the probability of one scenario or another (five to one in favour of the war continuing at least into next year). He insisted that I put everything on “zero”. Well, those were the rules of the game.

And so I placed my bet. Overcoming my irritation, I made my choice and took the risk of suggesting that the war would end before next spring, despite the fact that everything I feel, let alone everything I analyse, argues against it. Now, with a cooler head, I can try to explain my decision. Having searched my subconscious, I can say with confidence that the only basis for it is my deeply ingrained historical optimism.

Essentially, this comes down to the eternal inner conflict between the lawyer and the philosopher within me. The lawyer (who is now also a political consultant) understands perfectly well that literally every verifiable fact indicates that neither side in the conflict is willing to end the war on terms it finds unacceptable. This means that the war will continue until one of the sides experiences a collapse.

Generally speaking, wars of attrition of this kind tend to continue until a revolution occurs. The loser is the side that experiences a revolution on the home front first. Since there is currently no revolutionary situation in Ukraine, Russia or, even less so, Europe, there seems to be little reason to expect the war to end quickly.

So why did I make this risky bet, which could cost me dearly in reputational terms in just a couple of months?

The reason is that the philosopher within me is actively challenging the lawyer and the political analyst. Without denying any of the obvious facts that clearly point towards the war continuing for the foreseeable future, he senses something beneath the thick layer of these factual circumstances, something inaccessible to a positivist view of the situation that relies exclusively on visible and verifiable facts.

That something is the current of history. And in my view, it is flowing towards the conclusion of this particular story.

The formula I have followed since the very first days of Russia's aggression against Ukraine has been simple: the war CAN end only when, for every party to the conflict, the political cost of continuing the war becomes greater than the political cost of ending it.

The only adjustment I have made to this formula since then is the addition of another independent party: Europe.

My feeling is that, in this sense, the underground river of history beneath us has now stopped flowing and is accumulating its energy in some enormous lake hidden in the depths. From there, it will either be channelled towards peace through some artificially dug diversion tunnel, or it will come crashing down upon the entire continent as a deadly torrent of mud and debris.

But for the moment, the situation has reached a standstill at a point where the cost of continuing the war has become equal to the cost of ending it.

Until roughly the summer of this year, the situation remained unchanged: the price of peace was significantly higher than the price of war, making any negotiations futile. What is the point of talking about peace when no one can afford to buy it?

Now, for the first time, we have entered a period of strategic uncertainty in which none of the parties to the conflict can determine with sufficient confidence what will prove more politically costly: war or peace. Everyone is still determined to win (to achieve peace from a position of strength), but everyone is already beginning to glimpse the possibility of defeat.

This is the other side of wars of attrition. They do not end with the capture of the Reichstag, but with a revolution. Whoever experiences one first is considered the loser. Today, the spectre of revolution is already looming behind every participant in the war: for Zelensky, it is the Maidan; for Putin, a scarf and a snuffbox; and across Europe, the spectre of communism is haunting the continent once again.

The situation is such that, whether you like it or not, you have to keep looking over your shoulder. This nervous uncertainty is what makes the present moment so distinctive.

Zelensky is not sure whether European support will be enough if America pulls out. Putin understands that his salvation lies in escalation, but he can barely imagine where he might draw the line (perhaps in paradise, but where are the guarantees?). Europe does not know whether it will recognise itself in the mirror a year from now, after a right-wing wave, driven by a left-wing revolt, has swept across the continent.

For the first time since February–March 2022, this creates a powerful incentive not to test the patience of history (or God, for those who believe). A year ago, let alone two or three years ago, no such incentive existed.

Some were counting on "Khreshchatyk in three days", others on "coffee in Yalta by summer", and still others on the "decolonisation of Russia". But the result is what we see today.

We have now reached a point — for the first time in five years of war, excluding its initial "embryonic weeks" — when ending the war is at least theoretically possible.

At the same time, in my view, the alternative to ending it is escalation and the transformation of the war into a Europe-wide conflict (on this point, Marco Rubio and I are on the same side).

In other words, the choice is simple: either a compromise peace at the last stop on the road to hell, or hell itself.

Frankly, I see no other scenarios.

At this point, knowledge gives way to faith. I have always believed in the logic of history, which has consistently, even if by circuitous routes, managed to achieve its objectives. And that is why I am betting on the hopeless "zero".

Yes, I remember perfectly well that history knows how to stray from the straight path and sometimes, as in biathlon, has to complete a second or even a third penalty loop. That possibility cannot be ruled out now either.

If the current leaks about Putin's "wish list" reflect reality even partially, the only possible response would be the words Marco Rubio used about similar demands from Iran: they are "not just unacceptable; in some cases, they are outrageous, absurd and completely unrealistic".

In that case, another penalty loop of war.

If Europe continues to refuse to accept Putin's Russia as "a reality given to it through the senses", another penalty loop.

If Ukraine maintains the position that Putin is fundamentally incapable of negotiating in good faith, and therefore that no agreement with him is possible, then yet another penalty loop.

And yet history has demonstrated that it knows how to stay its course, despite everything and against all odds.

So, by betting on a swift peace, I am betting on history itself — on the rational and logical principle within our otherwise largely insane world.

It is rather like gambling in a casino, of course. But I have been to casinos before, and I have even beaten the house.

I hope to win this time, too.

Share this article

Facebook Twitter LinkendIn